Wednesday, May 7, 2025

Old Style Pizza Sauce - Like Back In The Day, Youse Know?

How about an Old Style Pizza at home?
I mean with a real, (mostly) naturally sweet sauce.  You know from a Pizza Parlor "down the way" that has a giant pot of the sauce perfuming the neighborhood as you get closer to it?

You may not have had one since the 1970s, but this sauce is it.  It's exactly how I remember it.


No this pizza sauce is not Vegan.
It is not Vegetarian.

It can be made either way, but while good, it won't be quite the same.


I take a cue from Mom here, and I get a pound of Stew Beef and brown it in the pot before we start this sauce.  Then add the ingredients to the pot and reduce. 

I have not tried it with meatballs but the flavor will be similar.  Just brown the meatballs and let the sauce cook it.

You will end up with some Braciole once you scoop it out, and if you have some extra sharp Provolone and some Amoroso Rolls, you are now having one of my favorite sandwiches from childhood.  Kaiser or a Hard Roll will work, as will Linguica or a Cuban Roll.

The recipe has Anchovies in it. You can leave that out but I would strongly suggest preparing it as is.  You will want that "Umami Bomb".



Ingredients:

  • 1 can San Marzano tomatoes (28 oz)
  • Half 24 oz bottle tomato passata (or strained Roma tomatoes)
  • 1/4 tsp pepper
  • Less then 1/8th red pepper flakes
  • 1 Tablespoon olive oil
  • Three anchovies rinsed and patted dry
  • 1 Tsp salt


Ingredients at the end:

  • 2 Tsp oregano
  • Tsp basil
  • 1 tsp sugar

Process:

  • Process anchovies and can of tomato’s in food processor or blender until smooth.
  • Add to pan with passata, salt, pepper and pepper flakes.
  • Rinse out tomato can with minimal water and dump water into pan - the object is to get the tomatoes out of the can so you don't have to boil a LOT of water down in reduction.
  • Reduce for hours low and slow simmer until thick and will cut with the wooden spoon in the pan.
  • After you remove from heat, add oregano, basil and sugar and stir in.  
  • Let cool and store.


No comments:

Post a Comment